For those of you who weren't there on Saturday (read: most of you), here's the gist of what happened.
We decided on a compromise, thanks to the tie in the poll, rather than defaulting based on my pick. We are using a historical Caribbean setting with Pathfinder levels of magic and non-human species.
The group was press-ganged from Port Royal, Jamaica in 1661, to serve aboard the Wormwood under the command of the notorious pirate Captain Barnabas Harrigan.
After a few weeks, the group finds themselves assigned to the skeleton crew of a captured merchant ship, under the command of the Wormwood's cruel First Mate, Mr. Plugg. Rumors abound that Mr. Plugg was planning to abandon his duties and take the ship as his own, not to mention killing off problem sailors (like the PCs), but any plans of disappearing with the ship were dashed when the ship ran aground just off of a small island after being attacked by a group of grindylows. In the aftermath, it was discovered that two sailors are missing, including one of the PC's friends, the cleric Sandara Quinn.